Study finds outbreak detection under-resourced in Asia

A new study led by Duke-NUS Medical School revealed that despite the recent pandemic, outbreak detection efforts remain under-resourced in South and Southeast Asia, with only about half the countries reviewed having integrated pathogen genomic surveillance initiatives in their national plans.

Published in Nature Microbiology today, the study also identifies key priorities to enhance the preparedness of the region against future pandemics.

The study, conducted over 12 months between 2022 and 2023, analyzes responses on genomic sequencing capacity for pathogen detection from 13 out of 19 countries that make up South and Southeast Asia.

The COVID-19 pandemic underscored the importance of genomic surveillance, which was vital in identifying SARS-CoV-2, monitoring its variants and designing COVID-19 vaccines. Initially focused on tracking SARS-CoV-2, these investments are now being used to address other disease priorities including drug-resistant tuberculosis, food-borne bacterial infections, dengue or to track the avian influenza A (H5N1) current outbreak.

While all 13 countries have national capacity for genomic sequencing, only 7 of the 13 assessed countries have integrated pathogen genomic sequencing into their national strategic plans for infectious disease surveillance. Additionally, only six countries have established guidelines for using pathogen genomics for infectious disease surveillance.

The absence of national guidelines for pathogen genomic surveillance complicates implementation and resource allocation. Closing these gaps is crucial for improving the effectiveness and sustainability of infectious disease surveillance and response systems.

Assistant Professor Ruklanthi de Alwis, Deputy Director of Duke-NUS’ Center for Outbreak Preparedness, said, “Although it is encouraging to see some capacity for pathogen genomics sequencing, including in lower-resourced countries in our region, there is still room for strengthening it.

“It is vital that pathogen sequencing is used to maximize public health impact through infectious disease surveillance, response and control. Assessing the current state and needs was a crucial first step.”

The paper also identified five specific challenges faced by the region in adopting genomics sequencing for infectious disease surveillance:

1. Funding: Countries reported a reliance on external funders for pathogen sequencing. Across the 13 countries surveyed, 57% of financial and other resources come from external donors, followed by the public sector (32%) and academic institutions (6%).
2. Trained manpower: Limited availability of trained laboratory staff and staff trained in bioinformatics for genomic sequencing processing and results’ analysis.
3. Cost: The cost of genomic sequencing-related equipment is prohibitively high and many resource-limited countries in Asia report paying higher prices for genomic sequencing compared with higher-income nations.
4. Supply chain: The supply chain for genomic sequencing equipment and reagents is sluggish, with new orders averaging two months to reach laboratories.
5. Turnaround time: Delays of several weeks between sample collection and the availability of genomic data hinder the timely use of this information to guide public health actions.

Dr. Thimothy John Dizon from the Research Institute for Tropical Medicine in the Philippines said, “The COVID-19 pandemic has served as a critical wake-up call for health systems worldwide, highlighting the immense value of genomics in combating pathogens and shaping public health responses.

“The intricate nature of genomics demands a transformation in our surveillance practices and has significantly bolstered collaboration among the Philippines’ public health laboratories, surveillance units and academic institutions.

“To maximize these advancements, it is essential to strengthen and sustain investments by fostering broader collaboration and partnerships both within the region and on a global scale.”

Dr. Khoo Yoong Khean, Scientific Officer from Duke-NUS’ Center for Outbreak Preparedness, added, “Pathogen genomics is an innovation with significant public health impact, and our entire region would benefit from guidance on effectively planning and budgeting for genomics.

“Asia faces a high risk of emerging infectious disease outbreaks due to factors such as dense populations, high mobility rates, poor water and sanitation conditions, frequent human-animal interactions, climate stress, and a rapidly changing environment. Strengthening early detection through infectious disease surveillance is crucial for regional outbreak preparedness.”

Methodology of the study

This study was conducted in collaboration with partners from Bangladesh, Brunei Darussalam, Cambodia, Indonesia, Lao PDR, Malaysia, Myanmar, Nepal, Pakistan, Philippines, Sri Lanka, Thailand and Vietnam. Participation was voluntary and the study included data from all 13 countries.

Key partners in each of the participating countries were identified to take part in an in-depth survey, resulting in a total of 42 major local institutions contributing data. These organizations hailed from diverse sectors, including government entities, academic institutions, public laboratories, and non-governmental organizations.

Based on survey responses, 25 summary indicators were then chosen and calculated to evaluate the regional status of pathogen genomic surveillance. These indicators cover areas such as partnerships, financing, policies and guidelines, supply chain, laboratory infrastructure, bioinformatics, quality assurance, and data sharing and impact.

The study was published under the Asia Pathogen Genomics Initiative (Asia PGI), a regional consortium hosted by Duke-NUS that is dedicated to advancing pathogen genomics.

The consortium has established a specialized training academy at Duke-NUS, enabling countries to collaborate through tailored programs that address priority health threats in Asia. Key partners in this work include the Bioinformatics Institute at Singapore’s Agency for Science Technology and Research.

In collaboration with the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (US CDC), Asia PGI is also organizing a joint workshop later this year on national planning and implementation of pathogen genomics for infectious disease surveillance.

Professor Linfa Wang, Executive Director, Program for Research in Epidemic Preparedness and REsponse (PREPARE), added, “While genomics is essential for surveillance, countries also need new tools in their outbreak response toolkit.

“PREPARE and Asia PGI will continue working with regional partners to enhance resilience to future epidemics and pandemics, and in the longer term, leveraging genomics capacity to rapidly develop new diagnostics and vaccines will be a crucial area of support for our efforts.”